Answer (1 of 5): The earliest soaps were made using ashes of wood or other plants, which contains potash (potassium carbonate). You can also use potassium hydroxide. These will produce a softer soap, and in the case of KOH, liquid soap. Those are pretty much your only practical choices. Alkaline
What are the ingredients in making hard soap? - Quora
Are there any alternatives to sodium hydroxide (lye) in making soap? - Quora
Why does oil separate in cold process soap making? - Quora
Why do you need lye to make soap? (FAQS)
Which oil is used in soap? - Quora
How to make organic soap without lye - Quora
What are the benefits of avocado soap for the skin, and how do you make it at home? - Quora
Can you make soap without using a lye at all? - Quora
How to make lye - Quora
What should I do to make safe soap bar? I was ordered to make soap only from sunflower oil. At first it was jelly but when I used sodium lactate it hardened